Broadway, Circle In The Square–January 22, 2006 (Adult Night)
Lisa Howard (Rona Lisa Peretti), Celia Keenan-Bolger (Olive Ostrovsky), Jose Llana (Chip Tolentino), Jesse Tyler Ferguson (Leaf Coneybear), Dan Folger (William Barfee), Derrick Baskin (Mitch Mahoney), Sarah Saltzberg (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Deborah S. Craig (Marcy Park), Jay Reiss (Douglas Panch)
Note: last known audio of the original Broadway cast on Broadway
Melbourne, Victoria Arts Center–January 25, 2006
Marina Prior (Rona Lisa Peretti), Natalie O'Donnel (Olive Ostrovsky), David Campbell (Chip Tolentino), Tim Wright (Leaf Coneybear), Magda Suzbanski (William Barfee), Alan H. Green (MitchMahoney), Christen O'Leary (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre) ,Natalie Mendoza (Marcy Park), Tyler Coppin(Douglas Panch)
San Francisco, Post Street Theatre–February 17, 2006 (4th Preview)
Betsy Woolfe (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), James Monroe Iglehart (Mitch Mahoney), Sarah Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Jim Cashman Douglas Panch)
Broadway, Circle In The Square–March 23, 2006
Lisa Howard (Rona Lisa Peretti), Celia Keenan-Bolger (Olive Ostrovsky), Jose Llana (Chip Tolentino), Todd Buonopane (u/s Leaf Coneybear), Josh Gad (William Barfee), Derrick Baskin (Mitch Mahoney), Sarah Saltzberg (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Lisa Yuen (u/s Marcy Park), Greg Stuhr (Douglas Panch)
San Francisco, Post Street Theatre–July 01, 2006
Betsy Wolfe (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (WilliamBarfee), James Monroe Inglehart (Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Jim Cashman (Douglas Panch)
San Francisco, Post Street Theatre–July 11, 2006 (Adult Night)
Betsy Wolfe (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (WilliamBarfee), James Monroe Inglehart (Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Jim Cashman (Douglas Panch)
Chicago, Drury Lane Theatre–August 6, 2006
Lucia Spina (Rona Lisa Peretti), Cristen Page (Olive Ostrovsky), Brad Weinstock (Chip Tolentino), Derrick Trumbly (Leaf Coneybear), Eric Roedinger (William Barfee), James Earl Jones II (Mitch Mahoney), Robin Alexis Childress (u/s Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Jen Sese (Marcy Park), Bill Larkin Douglas Panch)
Philadelphia–October 19, 2006 (Matinee)
Jen Simard (Rona Lisa Peretti), Lauren Worsham (Olive Ostrovsky), Miguel Cervantes (Chip Tolentino), Michael Zahler (Leaf Coneybear), Eric Peterson (William Barfee), Alan H. Green (Mitch Mahoney), Sarah Stiles (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Katie Boren (Marcy Park), James Kall (Douglas Panch)
Indianapolis–October 28, 2006 (Matinee)
Jennifer Simard (Rona Lisa Peretti), Lauren Worsham (Olive Ostrovsky), Miguel Cervantes (Chip Berkowitz), Michael Zahler (Leaf Coneybear), Eric Petersen (William Barfee), Alan H. Green (Mitch Mahoney), Sarah Stiles (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Katie Boren (Marcy Park), James Kall (Douglas Panch)
Boston, Wilbur Theatre–November 4, 2006
Betsy Wolfe (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (WilliamBarfee), James Monroe Inglehart (Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Daniel Pearce (Douglas Panch)
PDT tracked
Boston, Wilbur Theatre–November 25, 2006 (Matinee)
Betsy Wolfe (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), James Monroe Inglehart (Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Daniel Pearce (Douglas Panch)
PDT tracked
Boston, Wilbur Theatre–December 31, 2006 (Closing Night)
Betsy Woolfe (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), James Monroe Iglehart (Mitch Mahoney), Sarah Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Jim Cashman (Douglas Panch)
Chicago, Drury Lane Theatre–January 12, 2007 (Adult Night)
Christine Bunaun (u/s Rona Lisa Peretti), Cristen Paige (Olive Ostrovsky), Brad Weinstock (Isaac “Chip” Berkowitz), Derrick Trumbly (Leaf Coneybear), Eric Roedinger (William Barfee), James Earl Jones II (Mitch Mahoney), Christine Werny (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Jen Sese (Marcy Park), Gregory Mills (Douglas Panch)
Infinitejoys's master
Note: The "I Love You Song" was not performed that night
Broadway, Circle In The Square–March 18, 2007 (Broadway Theme Night)
Lisa Howard (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jessica-Snow Wilson (Olive Ostrovsky), Jose Llana (Chip Tolentino), Barrett Foa (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), Derrick Baskin (Mitch Mahoney), Sarah Saltzberg (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Deborah S. Craig (Marcy Park), Greg Stuhr (Douglas Panch)
Guest Spellers: Raul Esparza, Lea Salonga, Brian Stokes Mitchell
Broadway, Circle In The Square–May 19, 2007
Jennifer Simard (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), Maurice Murphy (u/s Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Mo Rocca (Douglas Panch)
Broadway, Circle In The Square–July 26, 2007
Carly Hughes (u/s Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), Maurice Murphy (u/s Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Daniel Pearce (Douglas Panch)
Samantha (Pyralisha's) master
Milwaukee–November 10, 2007
Roberta Duchak (Rona Lisa Peretti), Vanessa Ray (Olive Ostrovsky), Justin Keyes (Chip Tolentino), Andrew Keenan-Bolger (Leaf Coneybear), Eric Roediger (William Barfee), Kevin Smith Kirkwood (Mitch Mahoney), Dana Steingold (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Katie Boren (Marcy Park), James Kall (Douglas Panch)
Broadway, Circle In The Square–November 27, 2007 (Local One Strike)
Angelica-Lee Aspiras (u.s) (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), James Monroe Igleheart (Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Daniel Pearce (Douglas Panch)
RequiemofDarkness's master; Annegret tracked
Broadway, Circle In The Square–January 20, 2008 (Closing Night)
Jennifer Simard (Rona Lisa Peretti), Jenni Barber (Olive Ostrovsky), Aaron J. Albano (Chip Tolentino), Stanley Bahorek (Leaf Coneybear), Jared Gertner (William Barfee), James Monroe Inglehart (Mitch Mahoney), Sara Inbar (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Greta Lee (Marcy Park), Daniel Pearce (Douglas Panch)
Toronto, Elgin/Winter Garden Theatre–January 29, 2008 (Opening Night)
Roberta Duchak (Rona Lisa Peretti), Vanessa Ray (Olive Ostrovsky), Justin Keyes (Chip Tolentino), Andrew Keenan-Bolger (Leaf Coneybear), Eric Roediger (William Barfee), Kevin Smith Kirkwood (Mitch Mahoney), Dana Steingold (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Katie Boren (Marcy Park), James Kall (Douglas Panch)
PDT's master
1st National Tour, Sacramento, Community Center Theatre–March 14, 2008
Roberta Duchak (Rona Lisa Peretti), Vanessa Ray (Olive Ostrovsky), Justin Keyes (Chip Tolentino), Andrew Keenan-Bolger (Leaf Coneybear), Eric Roediger (William Barfee), Kevin Smith Kirkwood (Mitch Mahoney), Robin Alexis Childress (u/s Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Katie Boren (Marcy Park), James Kall (Douglas Panch)
Patta's master
1st National Tour, Sacramento, Community Center Theatre–March 16, 2008
Roberta Duchak (Rona Lisa Peretti), Vanessa Ray (Olive Ostrovsky), Justin Keyes (Chip Tolentino), Jeffery James Binney (u/s Leaf Coneybear), Eric Roediger (William Barfee), Kevin Smith Kirkwood (Mitch Mahoney), Robin Alexis Childress (u/s Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre), Katie Boren (Marcy Park), James Kall (Douglas Panch)
San Jose, Repertory Theatre–June 13, 2009
Alison Ewing (Rona Lisa Peretti/Olive's Mom),
Dani Marcus (Olive Ostrovsky),
Marc de la Cruz (Chip Tolentino/Jesus), Clifton Guterman (Leaf Coneybear),
Mark Farrell (William Barfee/Leaf's Dad),
Berwick Haynes (Mitch Mahoney/Dan Dad/Olive's Dad),
Molly Bell (Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre/Leaf's Mom(,
Sophie Oda (Marcy Park ), Steve Irish (Douglas Panch)
